Menu
Washingtoner
  • Home
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Health
  • Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Software
  • Business
  • Education
  • Real Estate
Washingtoner

Blaming Patients: How Failed Treatments Fuel a $51 Billion Brain Device Industry
Washingtoner/10288490

Trending...
  • Business News & Info Goes Inside Paragon FX Group's Hunt for Original Film Props
  • New Self-Service Sandbag Station at Tacoma Recovery and Transfer Center
  • City of Spokane and City Council Announce 2027 Legislative Priorities
CCHR's New Report Exposes Dangerous Devices
CCHR's New Report Exposes Dangerous Neurological Interventions Being Pushed on Veterans, Children, and the Vulnerable

LOS ANGELES - Washingtoner -- The Citizens Commission on Human Rights International (CCHR), a leading mental health industry watchdog, has released a damning report detailing how psychiatry is blaming patients—rather than failed treatments—to justify a surge in brain stimulation interventions. "When psychiatric drugs and therapy don't work, psychiatry rarely blames the treatment—it blames the patient, saying they are 'treatment-resistant,'" said Jan Eastgate, President of CCHR International. "'Treatment-resistant' isn't a diagnosis—it's a deflection. And it's being used to push invasive procedures like Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT), Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS), Vagus Nerve Stimulation (VNS), and Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS)."

These brain stimulation devices were "cleared" by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) or approved under Humanitarian Device Exemptions, bypassing the rigorous testing normally required of most medical devices. Many were greenlighted based on the device delivering ECT—a practice known for causing brain damage, memory loss, and even death[1].

Even industry insiders acknowledge concerns. "The precise physiological mechanisms of DBS are not yet fully understood," admits one clinical review.[2]  A professor of psychiatry at Brown University's Alpert Medical School, put it more starkly: "This really is a kind of mind control."[3]

The term "treatment-resistant" is a psychiatric sleight of hand, Eastgate says, now used to justify a global neurostimulation industry projected to hit $51 billion by 2030. Labeling up to 60% of psychiatric patients as "resistant" creates a false pretext for experimental interventions.[4] Meanwhile, 25% of patients develop psychotropic drug tolerance within weeks, prompting ever-riskier "solutions."[5]

Electroshock: Psychiatry's Recycled Blunder

ECT involves sending up to 460 volts through the brain to trigger seizures. Contrary to PR spin, Eastgate says, experts report modern ECT is no safer—voltage levels are higher than when broken bones were common due to convulsions.
  • FDA Loophole: Grandfathered in without clinical trials in 1976. In 2018, the FDA reclassified some ECT uses as "low risk," even for children as young as 13. Over 2,400 public comments opposed this.
  • Global Condemnation: The World Health Organization and United Nations consider ECT on children or the non-consenting a form of torture.[6]
  • Medical Harm: Neurologists equate ECT's effects to traumatic brain injury.[7] Patients are 44 times more likely to die by suicide than the general population. One in 15 ECT patients face life-threatening cardiac issues.[8]
  • Financial Cost: A $3–5.4 billion industry. Medicaid spent $9 million on ECT in 2023 in 27 states.[9] The VA and Department of Defense have administered it to veterans and children under age five.[10]

Deep Brain Stimulation: Electrodes are surgically implanted into the brain, powered by a device in the chest.
  • FDA Fast Track: Approved via Humanitarian Device Exemption for OCD in 2009 without efficacy data.
  • Harms: Stroke, hemorrhage, hallucinations, sexual dysfunction, apathy, and suicide attempts.[11]
  • Patient Testimonies: Participants in failed DBS trials report cognitive decline and emotional deterioration.[12]

Vagus Nerve Stimulation: Electrical stimulation delivered via electrodes wrapped around the vagus nerve.
  • FDA: Approved in 2005 for "treatment-resistant depression" despite lacking robust evidence.
  • Risks: Nerve damage, infection, hoarseness, breathing difficulty. The FDA has logged over 10,000 complaints involving death, injury, or device malfunction.[13]
  • Cost: Averaging $30,000+.

Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation: Magnetic pulses are aimed at the brain over six weeks.
  • Youth Approval: Cleared in 2008 for adults, and in 2024 for adolescents as young as 15.
  • Side Effects: "Brain fog," seizures, mood swings. One patient said: "This treatment destroyed my life… It gave me false hope."[14]
  • Price Tag: Up to $300 per session; full courses can reach $15,000.

Despite the sophistication of these procedures, there is still no objective medical test to diagnose any psychiatric disorder. No blood test. No brain scan. No biomarker.[15]

More on Washingtoner
  • Not a Black Box Launches TalentOS, the First Talent Harness Operating System
  • City of Tacoma's Adopted Biennial Budget Focuses on Everyday Services and Fiscal Sustainability
  • Spokane: Local Leaders Celebrate Community Redevelopment in East Central
  • A Diwali Celebration with Heritage at South Brunswick Residents & American Properties
  • Law Offices of Larry E. Bray, P.A. Wins Fourth District Appeal Clarifying Limits of Florida's Offer of Judgment Statute

Dr. Thomas Insel, former director of the National Institute for Mental Health advised: "Unlike our definitions of ischemic heart disease, lymphoma, or AIDS, the DSM [Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders] diagnoses are based on a consensus… not any objective laboratory measure."[16]

"It's not the patient that's resistant—it's the system that's resistant to accountability," Eastgate said. "In any other field, if the intervention failed, the treatment would be reevaluated. But psychiatry doubles down, pushing more dangerous interventions instead."

CCHR urges policy makers to: End all use of ECT and brain stimulation devices for treatment of mental issues, and end ECT's role as a predicate device for newer technologies. And support humane, non-invasive, non-drug, non-brain stimulation solutions that respect patient dignity and avoid neurological and other physical harm.

CCHR, established in 1969 by the Church of Scientology and psychiatrist Dr. Thomas Szasz has a record of reforms that include banning lethal Deep Sleep Treatment, outlawing ECT use on children in several U.S. states, and securing global recognition for patient rights. Today, the United Nations and WHO echo what CCHR has long fought for: coercion has no place in mental health care.

Sources:

[1] FDA, Final Rule on Electroconvulsive Therapy Devices, Federal Register, Dec. 26, 2018; WHO-OHCHR, "Guidance on Mental Health, Human Rights and Legislation," 9 Oct. 2023, p. 58, www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/documents/publications/WHO-OHCHR-Mental-health-human-rights-and-legislation_web.pdf

[2] Lavanya P. Sharma, et. al, "Deep brain stimulation – A primer for psychiatrists," Asian Journal of Psychiatry, Vol. 104, Feb. 2025

[3] Lavanya P. Sharma, et. al, "Deep brain stimulation – A primer for psychiatrists," Asian Journal of Psychiatry, Vol. 104, Feb. 2025

[4] "Treatment resistance in psychiatry: state of the art and new directions," Mol Psychiatry, July 2021, pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8960394/#fn-group1

[5] pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9332474/

[6] WHO- OHCHR, "Guidance on Mental Health, Human Rights and Legislation," 9 Oct. 2023, pp. 15, 58 and 59; www.cchrint.org/2023/09/18/who-guideline-condemns-coercive-psychiatric-practices/

[7] "Electroconvulsive Shock Therapy Lawsuit – What You Should Know About ECT," www.wisnerbaum.com/defective-medical-device-injuries/ect/

[8] www.cchrint.org/2024/11/08/veterans-day-cchr-calls-for-safeguards/, Peter Simons, "ECT Does Not Seem to Prevent Suicide," Mad In America, 17 Feb. 2023, www.madinamerica.com/2023/02/ect-does-not-seem-to-prevent-suicide/

More on Washingtoner
  • Holiday Magic Returns to Downtown Downers Grove November 27-29
  • What If the Greatest Gift This Holiday Season Came in a Dream of Your Loved One in Spirit?
  • Scoop Social Co. Brings Its Signature Mobile Dessert Experience to Minneapolis
  • LGF Lab Gas Flow Launches Fully Automatic Laboratory Gas Changeover Manifold System with Ultra High Purity Gas Regulator Valve
  • Record Q3 Revenue and Gross Profit Delivered: Revenue Surges 40%, Gross Margin Soars to 36% & Adjusted EBITDA Loss Narrows 64% for Cycurion, Inc $CYCU

[9] www.cchrint.org/2024/08/23/the-collapse-of-electroshock/ Based on Freedom of Information Requests to 27 states

[10] www.cchrint.org/2018/10/12/veterans-get-damaging-mental-health-deal/; Tricare Encounter Data (TED) Non-Institutional (Outpatient) for Purchased Care claims, Data Extract as of 10/21/2016, Data received from CCHR International Freedom of Information Request, 2016

[11] "Brain Stimulation Therapies," NIMH, www.nimh.nih.gov/health/topics/brain-stimulation-therapies/brain-stimulation-therapies.shtml, accessed 21 Feb. 2011; Dr. Ananya Mandal, MD, "Deep Brain Stimulation Side Effects," News Medical Life Sciences, 22 July 2023, www.news-medical.net/health/Deep-Brain-Stimulation-Side-Effects.aspx

[12] Danielle Egan, "Adverse Effects: The Perils of Deep Brain Stimulation for Depression," Mad in America, 24 Sept. 2015

[13] www.hg.org/legal-articles/patients-with-complications-from-cyberonics-vns-therapy-systems-may-qualify-to-file-a-lawsuit-49467

[14] FDA MAUDE report, Neurostar TMS, 07/14/2021, www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfMAUDE/detail.cfm?mdrfoi__id=15283600&pc=OBP

[15] www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/08/200817104247.htm

[16] psychrights.org/2013/130429NIMHTransformingDiagnosis.htm

Contact
CCHR International
***@cchr.org


Source: Citizens Commission on Human Rights International
Filed Under: Health, Government

Show All News | Disclaimer | Report Violation

0 Comments
1000 characters max.

Latest on Washingtoner
  • Commercial Sales for U.S.-Made, Preservative-Free Ketamine Amid Long-Runnin Shortage Following FDA Approval by NRx Pharmaceuticals, Inc
  • Stamp Me Launches Web App Ahead of 15th Anniversary
  • The King Returns: Satirical December 2026 Rematch Sees Challenger Delayed by a Christmas Light Installation
  • Spokane City Council Passes Chronic Nuisance Properties Ordinance
  • City of Spokane and City Council Announce 2027 Legislative Priorities
  • LCH2 Awarded Additional $1 Million to Advance Lewis County Clean Energy Campus
  • Security Planning Tips For Your Holiday Event From Access Patrol Services
  • Tacoma: Council Member Sandesh Sadalge Focuses Today's District 4 Town Hall on the City's Biennial Budget
  • City of Tacoma Awarded $2.25 Million in Federal Highway Safety Improvement Program Grant Funding for South 21st Street Corridor
  • New Self-Service Sandbag Station at Tacoma Recovery and Transfer Center
  • Contracting Resources Group Receives 2026 HIRE Vets Platinum Medallion Award
  • Business News & Info Goes Inside Paragon FX Group's Hunt for Original Film Props
  • Kitchen Table Economics: An Invitation to Think Differently
  • Win a $5,000 VIP Family Experience at the 100th Thanksgiving Day Parade in New York City
  • CB Stuffer Announces Private Sale to Secure Future of Brand Growth
  • The Fifth Annual "Bamboo Lantern Festival" to Illuminate Tokyo Mizumachi and Sumida River Walk®
  • Iglesia.com Positioned in Multimillion-Dollar Domain Market with $10 Million Asking Price
  • TCA VG: 2025 Funding Climbs to $9M across 43 Companies; Cumulative Returns Reach 5.3 MOIC & 22% IRR
  • Searching for the Next LBE Creator: CalArts Launches First-Ever D.R.E.A.M.S. Pitch Competition
  • Spokane: Gesa Pavilion Concert Series Welcomes New Concert Promoter
_catLbl0 _catLbl1

Popular on Washingtoner

  • Pre-Seed VC Martin Tobias Makes Fundraising Tool Available to Every Startup CEO as Investor Match - 327
  • New Research Spotlight, Expanding TUSC2 Science & Strategic Development Milestones Put Gene Therapy Innovation into Focus for Genprex (NAS DAQ: GNPX) - 284
  • LocalsVoted Launches: Local Rankings From Phone-Verified Votes, Not Paid Placement - 180
  • Simpalm Staffing Launches Tax Preparer Staffing for U.S. CPA Firms - 147
  • Sycamore Dove Releases "Loving Every Moment" - 124
  • One in three Americans may have lost track of retirement savings from a previous job - 117
  • Datavalet Named One of Quebec's Best Workplaces™ for 2026 - 113
  • Tacoma: OMWBE Active Certification Class on November 16 - 101
  • Nextlink Internet Deploys netElastic to Modernize Its Hybrid Broadband Network
  • ThriveStack citedby launches Prompt Research to find the prompts buyers ask in AI search

Similar on Washingtoner

  • PinnacleQM launches new enterprise website to help Australian organisations deliver more with confidence
  • Tacoma: Statement from District 4 Council Member Sandesh Sadalge and At-Large Council Member Olgy Diaz on Sale of Northwest ICE Processing Center to Federal Government
  • Tacoma Creates 2025-2026 Annual Report Demonstrates Continued Investment in Arts, Culture, Heritage, and Science Across Tacoma
  • Boston Industrial Solutions Introduces the New Volta® M100 Pad Printing Machine
  • City of Tacoma’s Adopted Biennial Budget Focuses on Everyday Services and Fiscal Sustainability
  • Spokane: Local Leaders Celebrate Community Redevelopment in East Central
  • What If the Greatest Gift This Holiday Season Came in a Dream of Your Loved One in Spirit?
  • Inaugural 12 Trees of Christmas gala raises $525,000 for DMG research and family support
  • Green Revolution CBD Spotlights Its Water-Soluble Focus Tincture With CBD, CBG and Lion's Mane
  • Tacoma: Closures Projected to Allow for Arterial Work
Copyright © 2026 washingtoner.com | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Contact Us | Contribute